Two purpose, Two efficiency.

http://q.hatena.ne.jp/1211450703

I answered yesterday.
my answer looks to be satisfy for the questioner the most.

Two purpose, Two efficiency.

and I thought the difference of between "web arguments" and "academic argument".

At first, we can confirm the difference of the two arguments is depend on the degree for referring previous researches.
Blog or someones argument on the web is allowed to discuss without refer previous research. Instead, if it is not interesting or not exciting kind of article, it will be ignored by everyone. whether the article is the re-invention of wheels or not is not important problem. On web argument, same thing, same opinion is allowed for everyone . While, Academic argument system emphasise on the connectivity of previous researches. if someones article can't connect previous researches, that article is considered "awful article".

why such kind of differ emerged ? Probably, it concern about the two system "efficiency".
The most important efficiency for academic argument system is not to back or re-wind the argument. Academic system purpose is the making achieve for all of human. On the other hand, web argument system don't has such kind of purpose. the most important efficiently for web argument system is depend on the situation. Frequently, it's for enlightenment or for launch for some of the argument....

I want not to assess academic system is more significant than web argument system. It problem has to consider in accordance with the situation. such as, argument about new phenomenon will be able to achieve good argument on the web. If it has not to connect previous argument archive web argument system, I feel the argument speed and quality is tremendous.